- They each retire with a $500,000 portfolio.
- They each withdraw 4% of their portfolio in the first year of retirement, then adjust that amount upward each year to account for inflation (as measured by the Consumer Price Index).
- Their portfolios are identical: 60% in Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund and 40% in Vanguard Total Bond Market Index Fund, rebalanced at the end of each year.
- The only difference is that Leslie retired at the end of 1994, and Bob retired at the end of 1999.
- 10 years into her retirement, Leslie’s portfolio had more than doubled, with an ending value of $1,062,606. (And 5 years after that, it had grown further to $1,105,982.)
- 10 years into his retirement, Bob’s portfolio was worth only $400,354.
They each followed the rules (more or less) with fairly conservative, low-cost portfolios, rebalanced annually. Yet because of when they retired, their retirements look very different.
Leslie will be (mostly) free from money worries, and she’ll be able to give generously to her children, grandchildren, and charities of choice. In contrast, Bob will have to be careful so as to avoid running out of money.
Why such a difference?
For the first few years of Leslie’s retirement, the stock market was shooting upward. In contrast, Bob’s retirement began with a 3-year bear market. When Leslie liquidated investments to pay for living expenses, she was selling high. Bob was selling low.
By the time the market began to rebound in 2003, Bob had already liquidated a good portion of his portfolio, so he didn’t benefit as much from the bull market as he would have if it had occurred at the beginning of his retirement.
In short, if you follow conventional investing wisdom:
- A bull market in the first few years of your retirement puts you on easy street, yet
- A bear market in the first few years of your retirement can mean money worries for the rest of your life.
Ways to Protect Yourself
What can you do to avoid finding yourself in Bob’s position during retirement?
1) Most importantly, lower your withdrawal rate. Many experts argue that a 4% withdrawal rate involves taking on very real risk of outliving your money.
2) If you don’t have enough saved to use a withdrawal rate lower than 4%, annuitizing a portion of your portfolio can be help reduce the chance of outliving your money. (On the other hand, it also reduces the amount you’ll end up leaving to your heirs.)
3) Take valuation levels into account when determining your asset allocation. In other words, it was a mistake for Bob to have 60% of his portfolio in stocks at 1999 price levels.
Be Your Own Fund Manager: For your after tax investments, Motif Investing allows you to build a basket of 30 stocks for only $9.95, instead of spending the normal $7.95 for each position ($230+ commissions). There’s no need to pay expensive and ongoing active management fees for mutual funds again. Once you build your own portfolio, or purchase one of the 150+ professionally created motifs, you can simple dollar cost average with one click of the button every time you have money to invest. You can even buy retirement Horizon motifs, that act like target date funds, except you don’t have to pay the 1% management fee either. Finally, you get up to $150 in free trading credit when you start trading with Motif Investing. Motif Investing is truly the low-cost, efficient, and most innovative way to invest today.
Updated on 2/8/2015. Let the bull market continue!