Structured derivative products are a type of investment that provide some downside hedges. They are also called structured notes.
I wrote this post back in 2012 after I got a six-figure severance. I was trying to figure out how to safely invest my severance with a hedge given I no longer had a job.
I’m revisiting structured derivative products now in 2021+ given the stock market is at an all-time high. It’s hard to invest in stocks at these levels and you may be finding it hard too. Therefore, perhaps a structured derivative product may help.
This article while share with you my experience investing in structure derivative products to protect downside and try to participate on the upside. As a family man now with a lot more wealth, protecting my wealth from loss has become more important.
Understanding Structured Derivative Products
I’m seeking yield to further enhance my passive income streams for financial freedom (highlights the various income streams). My current CD monthly interest income is around $2,800 a month and I’ve got roughly $225,000 in liquid cash that’s sitting in a money market account earning 0.2% interest.
Having $225,000 in a money market earning 0.2% interest is a lousy $400 a YEAR, which means I can’t even buy an overpriced iPad like millions of crazy rich folks are buying nowadays! The amount of money people have to spend on material things makes me so bullish about the economy. People don’t spend money they don’t have, just like I can’t drive a Ferrari Italia that I don’t own.
Everyday I keep my money in a pathetic money market is another day I’m missing out on free money. As such, I have been focused for the past couple of weeks on searching for ideal products to invest my money.
Narrowing the structured derivative products down to the following:
1) 2.3% 7-year CD with Bank of America. Guaranteed estimated return $5,175 a year / $431 a month and bringing my CD passive income to $3,243 a month.
2) 6-10% potential returns via peer to peer / social lending. Non guaranteed $13,500-$22,500 a year / $1,125-$1,875 a month. Have $50K ear-marked to this stream if and when the partnership comes through. But, could invest more if things work out well.
3) Structured CDs, with a guaranteed rate of 2% for the first two years and LIBOR + 1.45%. $4,500+ a year / $375+ a month.
4) Online trading via E-Trade or ScottTrade. No guarantees. + or – $40,000 a year.
5) Private equity investments. I’ve received a couple offers to invest in some start-ups in the Bay Area. 70% chance for a -100%, up to a 5-10% chance for a 500% return.
6) Rental property. Borrow at 3%, earn a rental yield of 8%. Estimated cash on cash return is 5% therefore $10,000 a year / $833 a month. Return on principal based on potential appreciation is different. Problem with rental property is that it is a PITA compared to online income or CDs.
7) Structured Notes. Similar to Structured CDs, but not FDIC guaranteed, and different return profile.
Not too narrow a list huh? The goal is to raise the $6,500 gross a month passive income to around $15,000 a month in order to have a comfortable lifestyle enough to take care of a family of four. The other goal is to have money work for me so I can focus on my business. The strictly passive income goal (excludes online and all other income) may change over time, but for now, $15,000 a month is what I’m shooting for.
If possible, please don’t get distracted by the capital amount discussed and if it helps, use whatever capital amount that makes you feel comfortable. The discussion focus should be on understanding structured products and feedback on a couple choices below.
THE FOCUS ON STRUCTURED PRODUCTS AS AN INVESTMENT OPTION
I like the dumbbell approach to investing e.g. high risk + low risk. As I looked more into Structured CDs, I’ve come to realize that structured CDs are exactly what I like! Structured CDs guarantee a minimum rate and up to $250,000 of your money back thanks to the FDIC insurance + it has an upside component to its returns based on a derivative.
Structured CD Examples:
1) A 5-year CD rate will guarantee you a 1% minimum return every year for 5-years. However, if Mitt Romney wins the 2012 Presidential election, the bank issuing the structured CD will agree to pay you 10% a year for the remaining four years!
2) A 3-year CD will guarantee you a 0.5% return for year one, a 3% return in year two, and 4% return in year three if the S&P 500 increases by 15% in year two, and at least 10% in year three. Every percent beyond 15% and 10% in years two and three will be divided 50/50 eg year two has a 19% increase, hence your 3% return gets a 2% bonus.
3) A 7 year CD will guarantee you 2% the first year, and 3.5% every year for the remaining six years so long as the CPI (inflation) index stays below 3.5%. Every 0.1% increase above CPI reduces your 3.5% rate by a commensurate 0.1% with a 2% floor.
So excited to start investing in structured CDs until I went looking for them.
I strolled over to Citibank to ask about their latest structured CD offering and to my surprise, they don’t have any! Disappointed, I asked what else they’ve got. Structured Notes of course!
Structured notes are investment products that are structured by the bank for their wealth management clients. The products have Initial Public Offerings and are NOT guaranteed by the FDIC. Instead, the guarantee, if any is based on the viability of the institution and the markets.
There are a myriad of Structured Note products, and I want to focus on two that sound most interesting and ones where I am actually considering putting capital to work:
Dow Jones Principal Protection Structured Note
* Minimum investment $50,000.
* 6 year note to maturity.
* Receive 0.5% coupon per year for 6 years.
* Receive 100-110% of the upside of the Dow Jones Industrial average from day of structure (May 24, 2012 in this case). In other words, if I invest $225,000 and the DJIA is up by 20% in 6 years, I will have made a $45,000 return + 0.5% in annual interest income for the duration.
* At the end of 6 years, I get 100% of your principal back at a minimum. If we go into a horrible bear market and the DJIA goes down 30% in this time period, I get all my money back provided the market is still functional.
* Opportunity cost is 2.3% CD – 0.5% coupon = 1.8% per anum I do not invest in the 2.3% BoA 7-year CD = $300/month or $3,600 a year.
* The return on the DJIA payment is a “bullet” at the end of 6 years. In other words, all proceeds are paid at once upon maturity.
S&P 500 Buffered PLUS Structured Note
* Minimum investment $50,000.
* 2 year note to maturity.
* Receive 0% coupon over 2 years.
* Receive a 10% downside buffer based on day of offering (June 4, 2012). In other words, if after two years the S&P 500 is down 12%, I only lose 2%.
* Receive 2X the upside of the S&P 500 in two years up to 18-22%. In other words, if the S&P 500 is up 5% in year 1, my return is 10%. However, if the S&P 500 is up 30% in two years, I don’t get 60%, but a max 22%.
* Opportunity cost is 2.3% a year to -92.3% of the value of my principal if the S&P 500 goes down by 100%, which is not going to happen. Also not allowed to receive the 2% annual dividend yield the S&P 500 is currently providing.
WHICH STRUCTURED NOTE WOULD YOU CHOOSE?
I like the S&P 500 Buffered PLUS note because there’s only a two year lock-up and has a nice 10% downside protection before I start losing money. My bogie for market returns a year is 3X the 10-year bond yield = ~6% at the moment.
If I can get 2X that return, that yields 12%, which is on par to earn a max two-year return of 18-22%. Although my bogie is 3X the risk free rate, I’m really always shooting for a 10% per anum return.
The Dow Jones structured note is also attractive because it proves a 0.5% coupon while I wait, returns all my money at the end of 6 years even if the markets go down, and gives me 100%-110% of the upside.
I’m a long-term investor, and if I can find a product that I like, the longer to maturity the better! The downside is if I do need to tap the $225,000 in capital, I would have to sell the note at a loss. There are no penalties, just the market rate for the note, as a large value of the note is time.
BEFORE YOU INVEST IN STRUCTURED PRODUCTS
* Understand yourself. You need to first understand your risk tolerance, income generating abilities, and capital needs. My preliminary requirements are that I want a minimum guarantee return of all my money back (principal protection), with a minimum 30% optionality of up to 15% on the upside, for as long a duration as possible.
Doing the math, If I can get a risk adjusted total expected return on my structured product of anywhere between 4-10%, I am a very happy camper because I expect inflation to be well contained.
* Understand the product. Make sure you have the banker explain everything in as much detail as possible. Ask for the downside risk and upside risk. Ask them to provide you examples of various return scenarios. Make sure you understand everything before you lock or invest your money away. Spend time reading the entire prospectus for structured notes!
* Focus on big institutions. I’m sticking with the big banks like Citibank, Bank of America, Wells Fargo, USAA, and Chase because: 1) They are too big to fail, and 2) I already bank with many of them, hence have more leverage. These aren’t fly by night banks, so I feel confident they will be around, or be bailed out by the government if they get in trouble.
* Everything is negotiable. Don’t take everything at face value. Ask for a better rate, or a better product. There is always something for everybody. I suggest you come in with as large a war chest as possible, but keep the amount hidden. The more money you have, the better concessions they will give you.
They will always ask how much you are thinking of investing. Start with their minimum… perhaps $10,000, and work your way up by asking with each increment what more you can get in return. When you anchor low with $10,000, and start speaking about $100,000 at the end of the conversation, the bankers will really start bending over backwards for you.
* Get motivated to earn more money. The banker’s minimum investment to open a structured product investment is $50,000 if I invest $100,000. Clearly the banker has incentive to bring in as much money as possible to earn a commission (1-3% of principal).
The point is, these products will only be offered to a minority of people because the banker only has so much time and is not going to open 100, $1,000 accounts when he can open 1, $100,000 account. Having a cash hoard gives you optionality to invest in potentially superior investment returns.
Update: I ended up investing $150,000 in the DJIA structured note and $75,000 in the S&P500 structured note $225,000 in June, 2012. I would not have invested as much in the markets if there wasn’t a downside protection component. The structured notes ended up doing very well.
Invest In Real Estate
Today, I’m more interested in investing in real estate over stocks at the moment. The value of rental income has gone way up because interest rates have come way down. It takes a lot more capital to generate the same amount of risk-adjusted income. Yet, real estate prices haven’t moved up nearly as much as stocks.
If you’re interested in a hands off approach to real estate investing, take a look at real estate crowdfunding. Once I had my son in 2017, I decided to sell my PITA rental house and reinvest $550,000 of the proceeds into real estate crowdfunding. My favorite two real estate crowdfunding platforms are:
Fundrise: A way for accredited and non-accredited investors to diversify into real estate through private eFunds. Fundrise has been around since 2012 and has consistently generated steady returns, no matter what the stock market is doing.
CrowdStreet: A way for accredited investors to invest in individual real estate opportunities mostly in 18-hour cities. 18-hour cities are secondary cities with lower valuations, higher rental yields, and potentially higher growth due to job growth and demographic trends.
Both platforms are free to sign up and explore.
Track Your Net Worth Easily For Free
The best thing to grow your wealth is stay on top of your finances by signing up with Personal Capital. They are a free online platform which aggregates all your financial accounts in one place so you can see where to optimize. Before Personal Capital, I had to log into eight different systems to track 28 different accounts (brokerage, multiple banks, 401K, etc) to track my finances. Now I can just log into Personal Capital to see how my stock accounts are doing, how my net worth is progressing, and where my spending is going.
Their 401K Fee Analyzer tool is saving me over $1,000 a year in fees I had no idea I was paying. They’ve also got an incredible Retirement Planning Calculator they launched in late 2015 that uses your real income and expenses inputted to give you an idea of your retirement future. Everybody should give it a try. There is no better free platform out there that is helping me manage my money. The entire sign-up process takes less than a minute and is free.
About the Author: Sam began investing his own money ever since he opened a Charles Schwab brokerage account online in 1995. Sam loved investing so much that he decided to make a career out of investing by spending the next 13 years after college working at Goldman Sachs and Credit Suisse Group. During this time, Sam received his MBA from UC Berkeley with a focus on finance and real estate. He also became Series 7 and Series 63 registered.
In 2012, Sam was able to retire at the age of 34 largely due to his investments that now generate roughly $300,000 a year in passive income. He spends time playing tennis, hanging out with family, consulting for leading fintech companies, and writing online to help others achieve financial freedom.
Updated for 2021 and beyond.