Do You Have Spending Guilt Or Frugality Disease?

My parents taught me never to order a beverage other than tap water because prices were astronomically high compared to cost.  Til this day, I still have trouble ordering anything other than a glass of water with a lemon slice if I’m going out to eat.  I start rationalizing how water has zero calories, is plentiful, and good for me.  Meanwhile, I’m craving the $6 fresh young coconut juice to go with my chicken satay at my favorite Malaysian restaurant.

One of the best tricks I’ve devised to overcome spending guilt is to actually purchase what’s desired, marvel at it through the duration of the return policy, and return it!  If there was a 30 day return policy on cars, I would literally be the most hated customer in the area because I would have no shame buying a new one every other month and handing back the keys.  I’m addicted to cars and their new car smell, even though I’ve stayed “sober” with Moose for over 5 years now.

OLD HABITS ARE HARD TO BREAK

Look down upon me all you want, but I’m telling you I have a frugality problem which needs course correcting.  Over Thanksgiving weekend, I decided to create a challenge to only buy things with only the money I earned online during that 4-day weekend.  Who the hell works online during those four days?  It caused me to think more deeply and go seek business.  I concluded that practically everybody outside of America works on that Thursday and Friday, and so I pinged my Australian and English clients.

I managed to secure $1,100 in online income that weekend and felt relieved I could go spend some money on some socks and business shoes.  I mustered up the courage the first week in December to hunt for my favorite Tod’s loafers at Barney’s.  They usually run $485 a pair after tax and are never on sale.  Miraculously, I found one good enough for my liking for “only” $315 after tax.  I bought them immediately and brought them home to admire.

I’m keenly aware that $315 is still a ton of money to spend on shoes.  However, relative to the income generated during the same period, it’s not much.  If I hadn’t made any peripheral money in addition to my day job income, I would definitely not go ahead with the purchase.

DEBILITATION STRIKES

It’s been over 10 days now and I still haven’t worn them outside!  Spending guilt has taken hold again, given these shoes are more than double what I spend normally.  I cannot fight the urge to return the shoes and go find some other sale for a third the price.  The kicker is that since Thanksgiving weekend, I’ve done much more online and still can’t manage to step outside and scuff the new soles!

By highlighting my monthly personal credit card expenses, I fear it’ll make me want to spend even less.  I even write posts expounding there’s no point making money if you don’t spend your money to will myself and others to stop being so frugal.  For the life of me, I can’t break free from my spending habits.

I’m curious to whether any of you also have spending guilt and frugality disease when you can afford the items?  What are some of the things you do to make you spend a little and not feel guilty?  Why are we so conditioned to act the way we do?

Photo: Tod’s Shoes. Are these shoes worth $315 after tax? I’ll wear them 5 days a week.  Sam

Regards,

Sam

Sam started Financial Samurai in 2009 during the depths of the financial crisis as a way to make sense of chaos. After 13 years working on Wall Street, Sam decided to retire in 2012 to utilize everything he learned in business school to focus on online entrepreneurship.

You can sign up to receive his articles via email or by RSS. Sam also sends out a private quarterly newsletter with information on where he's investing his money and more sensitive information.

Subscribe To Private Newsletter

Comments

  1. says

    They are beautiful shoes! I can’t tell with much accuracy from the picture, but they seem to be of very high quality, meaning they’ll last longer, which generally, for shoes, means they’ll even out in the end for cost-per-use if you’re taking good care of them!

    Great post! I’m checking out this challenge now; I definitely need to get a reign on my spending!

    • says

      They are well made and very comfortable. I figure since I will wear them 4-5x a week, might as get something of good quality. Kind of like a mattress.

      The challenge of making side income and use only the side income generated to pay for superfluous items is a good one!

  2. says

    Wow, Financial Samurai – you have the opposite problem as I do!

    I’m still trying to train myself to want even less stuff (my most expensive footwear is a $90 pair of Timberland hiking boots with over 3,000 walking miles on them now). Not because I can’t afford it, but because I find that wanting less seems to make me happy. Perhaps I’m addicted to minimalism.

    On the other hand, you appear to be making an absolute crapload of money these days, which would indeed present different challenges.

    You’re a really generous guy – maybe if you set up a big charitable foundation that did something like promoting entrepreneurship and scholarships, and mentally dedicate all your net worth to go to that eventually, (someday when you don’t need it), it would provide the “higher cause” that would allow you to feel good about your frugality no matter how rich you become, rather than guilty for cheating yourself out of killer fancy shoes :-)

    • says

      I hear ya. Desiring less and desiring nothing increases happiness for sure. It’s the Buddhist’s way!

      I plan on working on the Yakezie Scholarship/Writing Contest for 2012 agai . Perhaps you will help contribute and spread the word! Thx

  3. Jonathan says

    I have a degree of frugality disease, as you call it, but most if it is tempered by a lack of desire for stuff. I don’t care about clothes or shoes, don’t play video games (other than casual phone/computer games that are free or a dollar), I don’t crave splurges on expensive hobbies, and I enjoy a good meal at In-N-Out burger just about as much as a fancy dinner at a sushi place or steakhouse.

    That said, years ago I made a conscious decision not to be “cheap” like I always perceived my parents to be. I don’t believe in going somewhere on a nice vacation and then skipping the famous museum because of the $5 entrance fee (we may skip the museum due to lack of interest, but not because of the cost of admission). I don’t believe in going to a concert and driving around for half an hour to avoid paying $10 in parking and thus missing the beginning of the show. If I need to buy something, I will often buy the nicer and more expensive version if I feel it will give me a better value (longer-lasting, preferred features, etc.)

    I would not pay $315 for shoes. Heck no. There are many, many things I would prefer to do with that $315. Including burying it in the ground to be discovered years or decades later.

    • says

      I can relate 100% on not cheaping out on stuff that are truly important or things one will use frequently. Hence, why I decided to go on the nicer ship to Europe this fall for about $1,500 more. In fact, it’s the same reasoning with shoes since I’ll wear em so much. But since they are a material item that can be had for much less, I feel bad.

      Would you still feel bad buying $315 shoes if say you made an extra $10,000 in side income since then for example? If so, maybe you do have frugality disease!

      • Jonathan says

        Yeah, I wouldn’t buy the $315 shoes under any circumstances. The reason that the $10k in side income wouldn’t budge my position is that, at this stage of my life (age 27), any money not spent gets invested. We put away $4-$5k a month in our checking accounts (no, we are not tempted to spend it despite its accessibility) and when investment opportunities come along, we invest it. We just opened escrow for our second rental house and are about to make an offer on a third. In 10 years, if I’m making $10k a month in side income, and need shoes, I may look a little higher end (or my wife would – she does all my shopping fortunately). But today and for the foreseeable future, I have no reason to think that a $300 pair of shoes will do anything for me that a $30 or $50 pair won’t do.

      • says

        Cool. Sounds like a good plan to build wealth. So essentially, you are saying no amount of money made would compel you to buy $300 shoes.

        Do you mind giving me a lead to where I can buy $30 leather dress shoes? I’d like to check em out. Thx

        • Jonathan says

          Haha, to be perfectly honest I have no idea how much my shoes cost. I have 3 pairs of dress shoes for work and my wife bought them for me. She’s the queen of finding deals on stuff like that though so I’m sure they were all under $60. Probably not $30 though.

  4. mike says

    Well Sam, you and I are in different worlds. First, I wear shoes maybe once per 6 months. My work shoes I wear once per two weeks. My sneakers the rest of the time, and I buy them at Costco and Walmart, never paying over $20.

    You spend $315, who cares? You’ve got the money, it’s yours.

    • says

      Hey, if I can wear sandles or flip flops for half the year, I probably would too!

      The reason why I care is that it bothers me despite working so long and earning extra income I still feel guilty spending this money.

      • says

        “The reason why I care is that it bothers me despite working so long and earning extra income I still feel guilty spending this money.”

        I COMPLETELY HEAR YOU! I have been saving money from online ventures only for a new laptop…but I can’t seem to pull the freaking trigger! Even though I saved for it, I have allotted myself such a small budget and have spent too many hours searching.

        • says

          Maybe try and challenge yourself to make 10X the value of the laptop before you pull the trigger? I was gonna buy a new MacBook Pro on Black Friday, but spent $30 on a new OS upgrade instead and freed up space and improved performance. Gonna wait til next BF now!

  5. says

    I know what you mean. I still feel like I am in kindergarten and I have my ‘school clothes’ and ‘play clothes’. If I spend much on anything, I hide it away until I really need it. It is totally stupid because you would think that each use would bring the cost per wear way down.

    What would you do with the 150 extra dollars you spent on the shoes that makes you feel so guilty? You have the money, get those shoes out of the box and move on!

    • says

      Hmm, that’s interesting that you hide your nice stuff? Should you be wearing your nice stuff the most and chucking your bad stuff?

      Good point on what I’d do w/ the extra $150 dollars. Maybe go out to eat and stuff. Can’t think of anything!

  6. says

    I usually do not have spending guilt, however I only buy what I need (generally replacements) getting the maximum discounts I can find. If I can not find the item at a good discount (around 50%), I won’t buy it. For example, I could use a new terrycloth bathrobe. I generally look at stores like Marshalls, but there were none I wanted. I went online and found an $80 one on sale for $40. I like high quality at a low price, hence value conscious. It also lasts longer and provides better service.
    The guilt comes from what we learned from our parents. It skews our value system. As far as the shoes, I only buy highh quality shoes and keep them a very long time. I have a great pair of wing tips that are 33 years old. They still look great!

  7. says

    I have the hardest time finding shoes that fit and are comfortable so I only buy new ones when my existing pairs have totally worn out. $315 isn’t cheap but if they fit really well and you don’t already have a working pair I think it’s reasonable to keep them. My work shoes cost about $220 after tax and I get so much use out of them and they’ve lasted over 3 years already with a few more left in them. I dread shoe shopping so I tend to pay up for a pair that fits really well and will last so I don’t have to go shopping again for a while. Clothes on the other hand I get really cheap because they are much easier to fit and find replacements.

  8. says

    I came back to blogging for a reason – I have a spending problem and I want to change it. So, yes, I have spent $300+ on shoes before. But not because I wanted to spend actually. When it comes down to shoes, I’d rather pay for quality and get a pair that will last, instead of investing in ten pairs of crappy shoes. It all depends I guess.

      • says

        I guess no one wants to spend $300 on shoes but you see something that is really comfortable and great looking and you don’t look at a price tag too much. Unless it is waaaay over your head. :-)

  9. says

    Wow, Tod’s loafers. Nice! That’s Mrs. RB40′s favorite brand although she hadn’t spent any money on them lately. There is no way I would spend $300+ on shoes. I am way too cheap to spend that kind of money. If you love it, you should keep it. It’s a reward for working hard over the long weekend! :)

  10. says

    Interesting thoughts sam – usually I dont mind ordering things other than water at a dinner out, but usually when I do its booze – I think the mark-up on soda is high, and I dont drink it anyway. That’s the nice part about online income – it really makes spending a bit extra on yourself easier because you can just earn it back!

  11. libby says

    I say you strap on the shoes and run outside before you can think. lol. I sometimes suffer from the same and have to shove myself mentally to go against this frugal side of me.

  12. says

    They are very nice shoes, you have an eye for quality Sam. Marketing psychologists call this cognitive dissonance, post-purchse regret, or buyers remorse. It’s an internal conflict; clearly you can afford the shoes but you know you could purchase shoes that would meet your needs at a much lower price. It’s a struggle, and many people feel this.

    I struggled with this when I was younger. Now, with 3 kids, I am perfectly happy shopping for value over style.

    • says

      What about value and style? I wonder why value products can’t just be stylish too? Like, why can’t a car designer just design something that looks like a Ferrari instead of a Nissan Leaf? Doesn’t cost much to draw!

      • Jonathan says

        I’ve always wondered this too. My wife tells me that expensive clothes “fit better.” Why in the world can’t the cheaper clothing manufacturers figure out this magic formula of good fit and apply it to the cheap stuff?

  13. Norviz says

    Sam,

    Tod’s are nice, but they never fit me quite right. You made want to take a look at Ecco shoes. They are also very high quality (they used to get worn every day and were on and off many times a week due to the airport. The last set lasted me 4 years, and even then the insoles were what failed (even after replacing them). They are a nice middle ground at about $200. Of course if you break it down to a price per day or price per hour, I’m perfectly fine paying $.02 an hour for comfortable shoes.

    • says

      OK, will try Ecco. Never tried them on caught my eye, but will try.

      I think that’s the thing. I’m probably too lazy to spend hours looking for another shoe, since I HATE shopping! AH HAH! This is another enlightenment. thx!

  14. says

    I understand what you mean by having guilt about buying something so expensive when there are so many cheaper alternatives. However, you have earned them, you can afford them, and they will last longer than your other main shoes (just guessing here…lol).

    • says

      Who knows! Affording is one thing, eradicating the guilt is the other. This is what I’m having the most difficulty with.

      Guess there’s always an extra buck to save or invest. It’s never-ending.

  15. says

    I have spending guilt only on things I say “yes” to but feel coerced into purchasing. For example, I think our household is fine without a TV. (I really don’t own a TV). However, my other half is begging for a huge 60″ flat screen. Thankfully, he is okay with waiting but I don’t know if I’ll ever have the guts to say “okay, let’s get it.” And if I do, I know I’ll have huge guilt afterwards. Spending wads of money is just not a comfortable experience. ;)

  16. says

    All of you folks with Spending Guilt and Frugality Disease – SEEK HELP! You are hurting our economy. Don’t you know the world’s economic welfare rides on the backs of the US consumers? Get out there and spend your money! The world can’t survive if we all become savers.

  17. says

    I, personally, wouldn’t spend that much money on shoes, because that’s just not my thing, but I’d say if you want them, and you can afford them, then they’re worth it. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with splurging once in a while. (I actually wrote a post similar to this today.)

    Oh, and I’m totally with your parents on the drinks thing when eating out, though for me it only applies to fountain pop. The markup on milk and juice and similar specialty drinks isn’t too bad (high, for sure, but in line with the food markup at a restaurant) but the markup on fountain drinks is off the charts. A restaurant charges $3 for a coke that cost them (literally!) about two cents. I just can’t handle that one! Haha.

  18. says

    Shoes are my thrifty Achilles’ heel.

    I don’t have $300 dress shoes, but I’ll spend $80-100 on Onitsuka Tigers, which I wear into the office. I guess I could spend $20 on a cheap pair of shoes, but at the end of the day the difference in price really is marginal in the grand scheme of things.

    Won’t go cheap on jeans or shoes, though my idea of cheap is probably different from yours. Gotta get raw denim jeans – Levi STFs are the best at the price point of $40-50 on Amazon. Designer raw denim jeans are easily $200+, but some people love ‘em. Then again, jeans can be had for $20 a pair, but I’d rather pay $50 for a good fit.

    I guess the problem is the dress code! Ditch the dresscode, and the shoe spending isn’t a problem. ;)

  19. says

    One trick I use to more when it’s deserved is to purposely save or budget for that item first. I know I’ll feel less guilty if I feel like I’ve thought it out and worked to earn that thing, whatever it may be.

  20. says

    I don’t have spending guilt unless something I buy gets wasted. I figure I save most of what I earn anyway, so when I do spend something, I go for quality and am comfortable with it.

    One area where I spend a lot is on food. It makes sense to me; food is an experience (both of the senses, and a social one), food should be nutritious, and food can have a big impact on the environment and on animals, so it makes sense to always go with quality in my view.

  21. says

    I think I have frugality disease… at least with respect to clothes. I’m not sure I would spend that much on shoes. But you picked a good way to do it by trying to spend only “extra” money you made. Of course, if you would have made that money anyhow then that changes things. I have no problem with people who want something specific “finding” that money by working more or selling something to get that particular item, even if it’s a luxury. (Of course, if people are in a bunch of debt they probably should apply that same “gusto” to earning money to get their finances straight…). Two cents :)

  22. says

    I would have a hard time spending that much on shoes. My wife thinks I need to lighten up a bit and spend more on things. Even though I have plenty of money now I still like living cheap. I just keep reinvesting as much as possible.

  23. says

    I can fully understand the spending guilt… I have been talking myself out of buying a digital SLR camera for over a year now, despite having the money saved many times over! But from reading your comments throughout this post it is obvious you REALLY want these shoes and have justified their existence, so wear them and enjoy them and let that drive you to earn that much more extra income in January.

  24. Marissa @ Thirty Six Months says

    There are lots of worse things to be than being Frugal. I get spending as well now, oddly it wasn’t something I had experienced before.
    My parents, especially mom, is extremely good with her finances, and she taught us to be aware of our spending habits. However, the frugal mentality took a while to develop. Now I have to justify every big purchase.

  25. Annabelle says

    Hi. I’m trying to find answers on spending guilt too. I have advanced to the stage where I look truly shabby all the time in thrift store clothes and Payless shoes. Yet I work like a demon to make over $100,000 a year in a corporate job. Like you I bought pricey for me $100 sandals 2 years ago as an experiment and have only worn them maybe 4 times so I don’t ruin them. Lol, writing this makes me see how sick and silly I’m being. Maybe we need to start with small smaller indulgences, feel good about say, the $6 juice and take baby steps up from there. What do you think?

    • says

      Sounds like good steps to me! Sounds like you’ve got it worse than me w/ the thrift store cloths and payless shoes. However, those are great stores! The only thing I wonder is you looking “truly shabby”. Maybe grunge is back in?

      Where you favorite things the most!

  26. Annabelle says

    Ah, I did love the grunge era! Lol. But yeah, I’m going to treat myself to some new, needed, and well-deserved clothes at the after Christmas sales. I actually do think Payless makes sense for trendy shoes. You’re right, it’s great to wear the stuff you really love, not save it. Great post!

  27. says

    I think you made a wise investment on the shoes. Classic style. High quality leather. If you wear them every day to work 48 weeks in a year, 5 days a week. You are paying a little over $1 a day to wear the shoes. This is cost effective.

    If you have a sweater in your closet that you paid $100 for and haven’t worn it even once a year…then you have wasted your money.

  28. Joshua says

    I’m half Dutch, and my wife is still way more frugal than I. I have been taking about buying a big screen tv for years, but said I was going to wait until my 27″ tube tv wore out. We have the money, even have extra income, that would easily take care of this, but every time I mention it, I get the “whatever you think is best” deal. I feel I have earned it, but she is also right that we don’t really need it and we can still watch stuff on the old tv. Haven’t figured out how to deal with this. Wait until we have holograms in our living room?

  29. Doug says

    “One of the best tricks I’ve devised to overcome spending guilt is to actually purchase what’s desired, marvel at it through the duration of the return policy”

    There’s nothing wrong with returning something you decide you don’t want or like–but to make it a routine lifestyle choice ultimately passes the costs on to other people. I do not approve.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *