Let me say up front that day trading is a waste of time and money. You are much better off investing in long-term trends and dominant companies that are consistently growing their earnings. Day trading is the exact opposite of buy and hold investing.
I first started day trading junior year in college. It was an expensive endeavor since each trade cost $10 at the time and I only had a $3,000 portfolio. The most I ever made was $500 one day trading Books-A-Million stock (BAMM), which is now no more.
I continued to day trade all throughout my 20s while working on Wall Street. We were allowed to trade ETFs and individual companies that were not on the restricted trading list.
Day trading proved to be a career-limiting move because it was a distraction. I was pulled aside a couple times by my manager to tone things down, so I did.
Once I hit my 30s, I no longer day traded nearly as much. I realized I could make much more money if I focused on my career. Further, having to reconcile all my trades during tax season was a royal PITA.
Temptations To Day Trade Re-emerge
Once the Gamestop (GME) mania hit, thanks to Reddit investors, I had a dream about day trading glory. In this dream, I dreamt that Bed, Bath, & Beyond (BBBY) would become the next multi-bagger as well.
After all, if GME could turn into a $20 billion company overnight due to aggressive short-covering and retail buying, why couldn’t Bed, Bath, & Beyond?
Like GME, BBBY was going the way of the dinosaurs. BBBY was heavily shorted by the same hedge funds that shorted GME. At the time, BBBY had already started to move, but it was still only a ~$5.2 billion company.
I could not resist. I woke up at 5 am as usual, transferred $50,000 to my brokerage account, and prepared for day trading warfare!
Further, in the name of science and research for this post, I wanted to day trade to show you why day trading is a waste of time and money. Even with 23 years of experience day trading, it’s just not worth it. Here’s my latest day trading case study.
How To Day Trade
You’ve got to first set yourself up with a robust trading platform from a reputable brokerage house. Stick with the big guys like Fidelity, Schwab, Vanguard etc. They should offer real-time quotes and no fees so you can trade efficiently. They shouldn’t crash either.
Here are some important fundamentals about day trading if you hope to make money. Remember, you can easily lose money day trading as you can making money day trading in the biggest casino.
First, you must come up with a thesis on what a stock will do that day. In this thesis, you must decide your risk / reward ratio.
Second, you must define your trading channel. The trading channel determines the likely range the stock will trade in during the day.
Third, you must decide how much risk you will take. The amount of capital needs to be worth your while.
Fourth, you must close out all of your position by end of day. Taking on exogenous overnight risk is not advised if you are a true day trader.
Now that you know how to day trade, please don’t waste your time day trading! Your return on effort will be pitiful. And you will get stressed out.
Over the long run, market timing doesn’t work. If you want to time the market, it’s much easier to time the real estate market because it moves slower.
My BBBY Day Trading Thesis
Here was my set up for day trading BBBY on January 27, 2021.
- I believed BBBY would go up as investors looked to buy similar types of stock as GME that was heavily shorted. I believed my downside was 20% and my upside was 50% for a favorable risk / reward ratio.
- Once the stock gapped up at the open, I felt the trading channel was between $42 – $60 / share. Therefore, I was an aggressive buyer in the $40s with the hopes that it would trade in the mid $50s or higher. I believed the stock could fall to the mid-$30s.
- Next, I decided to day trade ~$55,000 worth of capital. I was willing to risk losing up to $10,000 to potentially win up to $25,000. At my brokerage, I’m in an account tier where I can transfer funds electronically and use the funds the same day.
To help get me motivated to day trade, I came up with a use of proceeds for any profits. My ultimate goal would be to make $25,000 so I could pay $20,000 for a new deck and fence at a rental property.
As I write my BBBY framework now, I realize it is much easier to write it out after the fact. I wasn’t this methodical before my day trading began. Instead, my day trading thesis all happened in several seconds. All I dreamt of was making some big bucks!
How Did My Day Trading Go?
I ended up making roughly $3,300 day trading BBBY on January 27, 2021 before taxes and a certain event that I’ll share with you below. $3,300 gross is better than a sharp stick in the eye. However, not great based on my investment thesis and my capital at risk.
At one point, I was down about $3,000 because I was buying on the way up and the stock corrected back down to the low. I had bought too much stock in the first 30 minutes, when the hype was the greatest.
If I was able to buy $50,000 at the bottom of the day (~$42/share) and sell $50,000 at the top of the day (~$52.5/share), I would have made ~$12,000. However, there was no way I could have done that because of two reasons.
- I was too scared to buy $50,000 worth of stock at once, and
- Timing things perfectly is impossible.
Here is the BBBY chart to give you a visual demonstration of the price movement on January 27, 2021. Sorry I didn’t take a snapshot of just the 27th. Notice the peaks and valleys, and the surge towards the close.
Poor Day Trading Execution
Because conducting trades is now free, I decided to just buy and sell shares in multiple tranches. This way, I would protect my downside losses. It’s similar to playing poker, where you “run it twice” or as many times as you agree with your opponent before the turn or the river.
I had imagined a scenario where BBBY would keep going up all day like GME did on January 26, 2021. However, when that didn’t happen within the first hour, I had to be more careful with my trades.
Below is a trade summary of all my BBBY buys and sells for the day. As you can see from the price progression, I was buying on the way up, selling on the way down (mistake), and then selling on the way up.
BBBY started the day around $42/share, got up to a high of around $54/share, and closed the day at $52/share.
Best Buy Day Trading Chart Record
|Action||Symbol||Security Type||Quantity||Price ($)||Amount ($)|
Made The Cardinal Day Trading Mistake
The reason why I didn’t walk away with $3,300 gross in day trading profits is because I also made one more mistake.
For fun, I decided to hold onto 50 shares of BBBY instead of selling everything before the close. I figured, owning ~$2,600 worth of BBBY wasn’t going to kill me. At one point, I had $61,000 in BBBY exposure that started making me feel uncomfortable.
I thought perhaps there would be a chance that BBBY gaps up again the next day. During after hours, BBBY was trading up another 8% to $56+. However, as you can see from the chart above, BBBY ended up getting HAMMERED down 40%+ to $30/share the next day!
What the hell happened?
Robinhood, the popular trading app that steals from the poor and gives to the rich, decided to stop letting its customers buy stocks like GME, BBBY, and AMC. Customers could only sell.
On a CNBC interview with Andrew Sorkin, Robinhood’s CEO explained his firm did so to “protect the firm and its customers.” What a bunch of BS! Here are some Robinhood alternatives because Robinhood sucks.
You can’t help protect ~52% of your clientele that owns these stocks by enacting artificial trading sanctions and crushing them. I bet Robinhood had a liquidity crisis or was pressured by Citadel, which is an investor in Robinhood and Melvin Capital, which was short GME and other names.
Retail Investors Are At A Disadvantage
The game is rigged against the retail investor. The game game is rigged against the middle-class family who can’t bribe their kids’ way into private school. The big guys tend to always win in the end. You must find ways to be your own gatekeeper!
Due to artificial actions by Robinhood, my measly 50 shares ended up declining by ~$1,000! I went from being up about $500 on 50 shares to being down about $500. Therefore, my net gain is about $2,800 gross plus any tax-loss selling benefits if I do sell.
I’m still holding onto the 50 shares because I’m interested in seeing what happens. On January 29, 2021, I ended up selling my remaining $50 shares for $39 when BBBY gapped up again. Therefore, I recovered $200 of my $500 loss (was a $500 gain).
Therefore, my total gross day trading gain before taxes was ~$3,000.
Why Day Trading Is A Waste Of Time And Money
Sure, I made about $
3,300 $3,000 gross day trading. I basically bought 1,313 shares at an average price of about $45.80 and sold 1,313 shares at an average price of about $48.20. I couldn’t time the bottom or the top.
However, if I had held onto all 1,313 shares the next day, I would have lost about $26,000! Holy shiitake mushroom, I would have been pissed!
And If I held onto all 1,313 shares until July 11, 2022, I would have lost about $50,000! Always close your positions by end of day you day trading maniacs!
Returns Aren’t Worth It
You can’t look at your absolute returns in a vacuum. I risked ~$55,000 day trading BBBY stock. $3,000 divided by $55,000 is a 5.45% return.
However, I was hoping for up to a 50% return. And secretly, I was hoping BBBY would double or triple given my original thesis: Why can’t BBBY be worth $20 billion if piece of junk GME was worth $20+ billion at the time.
The amount of capital I used to day trade BBBY stock is called “value at risk.” And I could have easily lost thousands of dollars day trading that day since I was down about $3,000 at one point.
It’s so much better investing in an a long-term trends. This way, you ride the wave and forget about the minutiae of trying to optimize the returns of individual investments.
Couldn’t Focus On Anything Else
A Day Trading Addiction Feels Bad
For the entire morning up until the market closed at 1 pm PST, I felt like a gambling addict. My anxiety shot up and I simply could not relax until I forced myself to take a nap. I had maximum investing FOMO, which is often worse than real estate FOMO.
Perhaps it’s because I’m not easily susceptible to addiction that feeling addicted feels so overwhelming. I couldn’t handle the rush for six and a half hours, which is why I had to take a nap so early! Usually, I take naps after lunch at around 2 pm.
While I was making several thousand dollars day trading BBBY, I was losing tens of thousands of dollars in my main portfolios. On that day, the S&P 500 and NASDAQ closed down more than 2%. This juxtaposition made me feel like I was really wasting my time.
Instead of day trading BBBY, I could have taken profits on some of my bigger positions and saved/made myself so much more! Or, I could have deployed my dollar-cost averaging strategy of buying X amount whenever the S&P 500 is down greater than 1%.
Reviewing my trades from January 27, 2021, I did end up buying about 40% of what I would have bought in the S&P 500 index. I was too distracted to follow through with my strategy of buying more when the index is down 2%+.
Please Don’t Day Trade
In an attempt to outperform, it’s worth allocating between 10% – 20% of your equity investments in individual stocks. However, I don’t recommend day trading with this 10% – 20% portion. It’s just too stressful for the expected returns.
Imagine being glued to the computer for 6-7 hours day trading and losing money! This happens all the time. It’s also so easy for traders to convince themselves they would have done things differently to make more money in the future.
You’ve also got to pay short-term capital gains tax with all your day trading profits. This tax percentage equals your federal marginal income tax rate. If you are in a higher tax bracket, your returns get culled even more. Thankfully, tax software and brokerage software today have made reconciling the trades easier.
Capital Gains Tax Chart
If you must day trade, then only day trade if that’s what you do for a living. Day trading is mostly done during the day, which means it will negatively affect your day job. Sure, you can take days off from work to day trade. However, I just don’t recommend it.
As you get older, owning many individual stocks may start to be a waste of time. They are hard to keep track of. Further, you might own too little to care.
Invest For The Long Run Instead
Your Return On Effort (ROE) will be much greater if you can just invest in a long-term winners and let it be. For example, I decided in 2016 to invest in various real estate crowdfunding projects in the heartland of America due to positive demographic trends and technology. I haven’t had to do one thing since I made my investment. Yet, the distributions are now regularly coming in.
The goal of investing is to make money in a way so that you DON’T have to work. By becoming a day trader, you are essentially working one of the most stressful jobs in the world!
I worked with sales traders, position traders, and algo traders closely for 13 years. Those guys were not a healthy bunch. Their mood swings were intense as yours will be too if you decide to come a day trader.
Yes, you will see day traders over social media highlighting their huge wins. But chances are, you won’t be able to replicate their success.
Speculate With 10% Of Your Capital Or Less
For the vast majority of us, the real wealth will be gained by making long-term investments.
Resist FOMO if you can! Let me leave you with my favorite day trading commercial by E*Trade, which also rigged the system by halting trades in name like GME. It encapsulates a day trader’s motions perfectly. May good fortune be with you!
Wealth Management Recommendation
Stay on top of your overall finances by signing up with Personal Capital. PC is a free online tool I’ve used since 2012 to help build wealth.
Before Personal Capital, I had to log into eight different systems to track 35 different accounts. Now I can just log into Personal Capital to see how my stock accounts are doing. I can easily track my net worth and spending as well.
Personal Capital’s 401(k) Fee Analyzer tool is saving me over $1,700 a year in fees. Finally, there is a fantastic Retirement Planning Calculator to help you manage your financial future.
Personal Capital will help you focus on the long game so that years from now, you’ll be thankful to have stayed on top of your finances. Using a free wealth management app like Personal Capital will help you become a good-enough investor so you can focus your time doing more enjoyable things.
Steadier Returns Through Real Estate
Instead of day trading, consider investing in real estate over the long-run instead. Real estate is my favorite way to achieving financial freedom because it is a tangible asset that is less volatile, provides utility, and generates income.
Given interest rates have come way down, the value of rental income has gone way up. The reason why is because it now takes a lot more capital to generate the same amount of risk-adjusted income. Yet, real estate prices have not reflected this reality yet, hence the opportunity.
Take a look at my two favorite real estate crowdfunding platforms.
Fundrise: A way for accredited and non-accredited investors to diversify into real estate through private eREITs. Fundrise has been around since 2012 and has consistently generated steady returns, no matter what the stock market is doing. For most people, investing in a diversified eREIT is the easiest way to gain exposure.
CrowdStreet: A way for accredited investors to invest in individual real estate opportunities mostly in 18-hour cities. 18-hour cities are secondary cities with lower valuations, higher rental yields, and potentially higher growth due to job growth and demographic trends.
I’ve personally invested $810,000 in real estate crowdfunding across 18 projects to take advantage of lower valuations in the heartland of America. My real estate investments account for roughly 50% of my current passive income of ~$300,000.
Readers, anybody like to day trade? How can there not be some major repercussions after this brokerage and shorting debacle? Are you willing to invest with a brokerage that can randomly shut off your ability to buy certain stocks?
For more nuanced personal finance content, join 55,000+ others and sign up for the free Financial Samurai newsletter and posts via e-mail. Financial Samurai is one of the largest independently-owned personal finance sites that started in 2009.