The Benefits Of A Backdoor Roth IRA

Backdoor Roth IRA - Horseback ridingIs A Backdoor Roth IRA A Good Move?” on Daily Capital is probably the best post on the internet that explains who should do a backdoor Roth IRA, how to do a backdoor Roth IRA, who is allowed to do a backdoor Roth IRA, the risks of a backdoor Roth IRA, and who doesn’t need to do a backdoor Roth IRA. Have a read and I’m sure you’ll agree.

Long time readers know that I’m one of the biggest detractors of the Roth IRA program. The main reality is: most people will make less in retirement than during their working years. Therefore, taxes should be lower, all things being equal. I present many more arguments as to why a Roth IRA is suboptimal.

But after spending some time editing the Daily Capital post, I’ve come around to the idea that for some people, a backdoor Roth IRA is a good move. Here are three main reasons why a backdoor Roth IRA should be considered.

The 401(k) Participation Rate Is Shocking

Just Out Of ReachAccording to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, only about 55% of the American workforce has access to a 401(k) and only about 38% of the total workforce participate. Doing some low level math, that means roughly 31% of those who have access to a 401(k) are not participating. What are people doing with their money? FOMOing?

At a 38% total workforce 401(k) participation rate, no wonder why everybody is worried about retirement. With 31% of workers with access to a 401(k) not participating, this looks a whole lot like self-inflicted pain, which is one reason why the wealth gap continues to increase. Even though I recently wrote about the average 401(k) balance finally breaching $100,000, we’ve still got a long way to go.

The reason why I’ve been such an avid 401(k) contributor my entire career is because I knew I didn’t want to get in at 5:30am in the morning and leave after 7:30pm for the rest of my life. The only way to extricate myself from a tiring life was to save and save some more. Besides, once your 401(k) is set up, saving becomes easy due to automatic deductions.

Now that I’m out of the work force, I think it’s a duty to expound upon the reasons why everybody with access to a tax-advantaged retirement plan should contribute. Once we get the participation rate up, then we can work on increasing the savings amounts. Let’s begin.

Reflecting On Two Years Of Freedom From Work

Why work when you can SCUBA?March 2014 officially marks my two year anniversary since I last held a full-time job. It’s been an amazing two years, filled with uncertainty and excitement as I worked to balance play with trying to feel useful.

To keep some discipline, I created a “production schedule” that officially began at 7:30am and ended at 11:30am. Sometimes I’d cheat by calling it quits before 10am because there was nothing left to do. Other times I’d keep going because I’d get hooked on what was happening in the stock market until it closed at 1pm PST. By spending three to four hours a day trying to produce something – writing in my case – I would never feel guilty spending the rest of the day doing whatever I wanted.

“Feeling useful” is probably the single most important attribute I’ve needed to experience during this time away. I’ve spoken to other people who no longer have to work and everyone agreed they need something meaningful to do in order to feel fulfilled. I’m thankful this site provides an easy way to add some value to society, no matter how small it may be. If you’re an early retiree who is bored and would like to share some insights, I’d be happy to publish your post here.

This post will share with you some thoughts after two years of being away from the days of always wanting to get paid and promoted faster. I’ve written a similar post about what early retirement feels like, but that post was written immediately after emancipation – like when Andy Dufresne from Shawshank Redemption finally broke free. 

Either Zillow Is Broken Or We’re In A Massive Housing Bubble

In January 2014 I wrote a post entitled, “Exploit Online Data To Lower Your Property Taxes“. In the post I highlighted a chart of my house’s estimate value by Zillow. The chart looks like a internet stock from 1999-2000. The chart significantly impedes my efforts to lower my property taxes this year because property assessors use online sources such as Zillow to partly make their assessments.

Since the publication of the post, the chart has continued to go up every day (see below). We’re now close to 300 days in a row of price increases according to Zillow. Are you looking at a new billionaire in the making who only hangs out with super models? Or is Zillow completely wrong? There is no way my home price could be up 60% since May 2013. Furthermore, there is no way prices can rise every day in a straight line for 10 months in a row. Just looking at the gap between the bold blue line and the dotted line (average price of my area) shows things are out of whack.

Thank goodness San Francisco is limited to raising property taxes by around 3%. But for someone like me who was able to successfully lower my property valuation for years, I will now be reset back to the original assessed value +3% a year catchup if I fail this year.

Housing Bubble Chart

Zillow is either broken, or San Francisco is in a massive housing bubble. Thanks to the robust growth of tech companies here in the Bay Area (e.g. Facebook at record highs, AirBNB and DropBox going public next, etc), I don’t think San Francisco is in a housing bubble. I don’t even have to mention rent control, land restrictions, good weather, and an international city as other reasons for propping up demand. We’re probably in the sixth inning of a dramatically tight ball game. 

Financial Disconnect Or Financial Awareness?

Picanha - Best Brazilian Meat

Just order picanha and skip everything else!

One of my new favorite restaurants in San Francisco is Espestus Churrascaria. The restaurant serves good old fashion Brazilian meat that is more tasty than some of the finest dry-aged rib-eyes. Ever since visiting Rio de Janeiro in 2006 during business school, I’ve been craving to eat some Picanha (rump cap) until finally my best friend took me to Espestus last month.

After going without picanha for eight years, I wanted to return just a month later. Perhaps one of the main reasons why I never went was because of the cost. At $74 a person after tax and tip for food alone, Espestus costs a pretty penny! Instead of just going with my friend the second time around, I asked her if she’d like to invite another couple friend of ours to make it four.

Here’s her text response: Too expensive for them.

Espetus is surely an expensive place to eat, but our friends are in their late 30s, rent a $3,700 a month apartment and drive a 2010 Porsche Cayenne. The husband also has a $10,000 motorbike.

Here’s my text response to my friend: Ask them anyway. They drive a Porsche that costs literally 15X more than Moose!

She texts back: OK, I’ll see. 

The Only Reasons To Ever Contribute To A ROTH IRA

Government Pork SpendingIt’s been a while since I published, “Disadvantages Of A ROTH IRA: Not All Is What It Seems” and since that time, hundreds of thousands of folks have decided to think more carefully about their retirement savings strategy. One of the main things people have learned is that the government manipulates individuals into forking over more money than they otherwise should due to gross mismanagement of their own budget. Massive deficit? Let’s announce this huge “benefit” to allow people to convert their pre-tax retirement funds into a ROTH IRA! We’ll raise the spectre of higher tax rates to get more people to bite.

It’s sometimes daunting to go against the government because they employ some of the smartest people on Earth to keep themselves in power while keeping the rest of us dependent on their largess. But I’m here to help you fight back and live a better life.

If you contribute to a ROTH IRA or convert your pre-tax retirement accounts into a ROTH IRA, you aren’t going to be damned to hell. You’re just not maximizing your wealth over time. I’m a rational person who likes to see both sides of the story. So let me share with you the only legitimate reasons why one should ever contribute to a ROTH IRA.

For those of you who already have a ROTH IRA account, what you are about to read probably makes so much sense you might feel a little bad. But don’t worry. The number one solution when you are in a hole is to stop digging and slowly climb out.